Anal play is more popular than ever and honestly, it’s not hard to see why. When you use the right toy, it can feel incredible. But finding that right toy takes a bit of know-how, especially if you’re new to it.
This guide covers the best anal sex toys for women in 2026. Whether you’re just getting started or you already know what you like, there’s something here for you.
What to Look for Before You Buy?
Before we get into the picks, a few things matter more than brand names or price tags.
Flared base. This is non-negotiable for anal toys. Every toy you use anally needs a flared base or retrieval cord. The anal canal doesn’t have a natural stopping point, so this keeps things safe.
Material. Body-safe silicone is the gold standard. It’s non-porous, easy to clean, and soft against skin. Avoid jelly or rubber toys — they’re porous and harder to sanitise properly.
Size. Start smaller than you think you need to. You can always size up. Going too big too soon is uncomfortable and puts you off the whole thing.
Lube. You need it. The anus doesn’t self-lubricate. Use a good water-based lube with silicone toys, and reapply as needed.
Rocks Off Silhouette Dark Desires Kit
The Best Anal Sex Toys for Women in 2026
- Butt Plugs — Best for Beginners
A butt plug is the most common starting point, and for good reason. You insert it, and it stays in place. That fullness creates a different kind of sensation — either solo or during sex.
Look for a slim, tapered plug with a wide flat base. Silicone ones warm to your body temperature quickly, which makes the whole experience more comfortable.
At For the Closet, we stock butt plugs in a range of sizes, so you can find something that suits where you are right now — not where you think you should be.
Good for: beginners, wearing during sex, adding sensation without penetration.
Love to Love Twinny Bud Vibrating Butt Plug
- Vibrating Anal Plugs — More Sensation, Same Simplicity
If you like the idea of a butt plug but want more stimulation, a vibrating version adds a new layer. The vibrations travel through the tissue and can enhance clitoral or vaginal stimulation at the same time.
Some have a remote control, which is handy whether you’re using it solo or with a partner.
Good for: those who’ve tried plugs and want more, couples play, layered stimulation.
Naughty Bits Butt Balls Silicone Booty Beads
- Anal Beads — Build-Up Sensation
Anal beads are a string of graduated beads — small at one end, larger as you go. You insert them slowly and remove them at the point of orgasm for an intensified finish.
They’re simple, effective, and great if you like the feeling of insertion rather than fullness. Opt for a set made from silicone or ABS plastic, both of which are body-safe.
Good for: people who enjoy the insertion sensation, orgasm enhancement, gradual stretching.
Nexus Vibro
- Prostate-Style Curved Toys — Yes, Women Can Use These Too
Curved toys designed for prostate stimulation actually work well for women too. The curve targets the back wall of the vagina through the anal canal, which can create deep internal pressure. Some women find this leads to more intense orgasms.
It’s not for everyone, but it’s worth knowing about if you’re curious about deeper stimulation.
Good for: Internal pressure sensation, people who enjoy G-spot adjacent stimulation, experimenting with angles.
Translucence Junior Dong Pink
- Anal Dildos, For Those Who Want More
If you’ve moved beyond plugs and want something more substantial, anal dildos are the next step. They’re longer than plugs and designed specifically for thrusting.
Stick to smooth designs without sharp ridges when you’re starting out. Texture is great, but save it for when you’re more comfortable.
Good for: those with anal experience, solo play, strap-on use.
ID Velvet 1oz Lubricant
A Note on Lube
It’s worth saying again — lube makes everything better and safer. Use more than you think you need. A water-based lube works with all toy materials. If you’re using a non-silicone toy, silicone lube is thicker and lasts longer.
We stock a good range of lubricants at For the Closet if you need to grab some alongside your toy.
How to Clean Anal Toys?
Clean your toys before and after every use. Silicone, glass, and stainless steel toys can be boiled or put in the dishwasher (without soap) if they don’t have a motor. For vibrating toys, use a toy cleaner or mild soap and warm water, then dry fully before storing.
We carry sex toy cleaners if you want something specifically designed for the job.
Conclusion
Anal play can be a genuinely enjoyable part of your sex life. The key is starting slow, using lube, and picking a toy that fits where you are right now — not where you think you should be.
Browse our full range of anal sex toys at For the Closet. We offer discreet plain packaging, free delivery on orders over £40, and free batteries with every toy that needs them. So you’re ready to go from the start.
